Mr. Bernanke Needs to Speak Out About QE3...or, Has He?

Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke takes pride in the fact that he has increased he openness of the Fed and has helped to provide greater transparency into the understanding of what the Federal Reserve is doing with regards to monetary policy.

Right now, however, he is staying pretty silent. 

The market concern is about whether or not the Federal Reserve is going to engage in another round of quantitative easing…QE3.

I believe that Mr. Bernanke is staying quiet at this point for political reasons. 

He stated just the other day that the Federal Reserve is not swayed by political factors.

We can save the further discussion about the political nature of the Fed for another day.

The Fed’s dilemma right now is that if jumps into an overt position on implementing QE3 it will be accused of acting for political reasons.

The Republicans will jump all over a Federal Reserve that seems to be “pumping up” the economy right before the election.  Should the Federal Reserve begin a QE3 before the November election, it…the Fed…will be accused of supporting a desperate president in his bid for re-election.  How political can this be?

The Fed has published the minutes of its last Open Market Committee meeting and the discussions within the committee showed mixed feelings about starting up a QE3.  But, even the weak economic information released in the last week or so have not been severe enough to change the minds of the decision makers…and, especially Bernanke.

The minutes do reflect that the Fed is keeping a watchful eye on the economy.  The Fed has promised to act strongly if the economic situation gets much worse.

There is real concern, however, over just how much monetary policy can do at this particular time.  First, there is the concern that it can do little to impact the unemployment rate.  The unemployment rate is a “real” economic variable and is determined by “real” economic variables.  Monetary polity does not work with “real” economic variables.

Second, there is the time lag in the effect that monetary policy has on the economy.  One can argue that the Fed has done all it can do to impact the economy over the next six- to nine-months and that anything else done now would have next to no effect on the economy before the November election.

This presents the question to Open Market Committee members: “Why start out now on a major monetary initiative like QE3 which would bring about tremendous political criticism when this initiative would have next to no impact on the economy before the election?”

The most the Federal Reserve can do at this time to generate confidence is to assure the financial markets that “if the economy gets worse” that it would take appropriate actions to combat a worsening situation.  And, Fed officials must continually provide evidence that it is “on the watch” and ready to move. 

The release of the minutes of the Open Market Committee serves this purpose.   The essence of the minutes was the split between committee members over whether or not the Fed should engage in further easing.

The other major issue besides the state of the economy, which will not go away is the condition of the banking industry.  Readers of this blog know my position on this:  the banking system is still quite fragile with many banks still unsure about the value of their assets, especially in the areas of residential real estate and commercial real estate. 

I believe that the Federal Reserve feels comfortable that it has done what it can to keep the banking system functioning and that the injection of $1.5 trillion in excess reserves into the banks allows the banking system to continue to function smoothly so that the FDIC can continue to close banks without creating significant disruptions to the industry.

Through the first half of 2012, more than one bank is still being closed every week at least one other bank per week is acquired and hence is merged out of existence.  The banking system continues to shrink!

There is little else the Federal Reserve can do at this time with respect to the health of the banking system.

Can Mr. Bernanke tell us all of this in a way that will convince us?  Should Mr. Bernanke tell us all of this in an attempt to convince us?

My belief is that Mr. Bernanke has already told us all that he is going to tell us at this time.  Mr. Bernanke has told us that the Federal Reserve is not going to act in a political way.  In other words, for the near term, the Fed is going to do pretty much what it has been doing in the recent past.  It will continue to try and “twist” interest rates, but no new excess reserves will be created in this effort.  And, the Federal Reserve will continue to watch the economy closely and stands ready to act if it appears as if the economy is sinking into another recession.  But, don’t expect anything more.

Other than the fact that I don’t believe that “operation twist” can really be effective, I believe that Mr. Bernanke and the Fed are “spot on” concerning what monetary policy should be at this time.  To me, the primary thing that is currently impacting US Treasury rates is the “flight to quality” in financial markets that is taking place internationally and this is dominating what the Fed is doing and everything else.