Showing posts with label problem banks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label problem banks. Show all posts

Monday, May 28, 2012

The Condition of the Banking System: March 31, 2012


 The FDIC banking statistics for March 31, 2012 were released last week.  There is room for hope in the statistics, but we are still not out-of-the-woods, yet.

The FDIC press release trumpeted the fact that the number of commercial banks on the FDIC list of problem banks fell for the fourth quarter in a row and reached a total of 772 banks, which was the lowest level this list has seen since year-end 2009. 

However, there are still 772 commercial banks on the problem list, which is more than 12 percent of the total number of commercial banks in existence. 

Only 16 commercial banks were closed in the first quarter of 2012, but there were 27 fewer banks in existence at the end of the quarter than there were at the end of 2011.

Over the last 12 months the number of commercial banks in the banking system declined by 190 and only 82 of these were closed. 

So, the banking system continues to decline with the majority of banks leaving the system due to merger or acquisition.  The vast majority of the decline (175 banks) is in the smaller banks (banks with assets of less than $100 million) where most of the problems seem to center. 

Over the past five years, the number of commercial banks in the banking system has declined by almost 1,000 banks.  The number of the smaller banks leaving the industry over this five-year period totaled 1,110!

At the end of the first quarter of 2012, there were only 6,263 FDIC-insured commercial banks in the industry. 

Even though the number of FDIC bank closures has dropped substantially in recent quarters, mergers and acquisitions continue to take place at a fairly rapid pace. 

I believe that we will continue to see results like this over the next several years.  The number of commercial banks in the banking system will continue to decline as troubled small- and medium-sized banks continue to be acquired.  If the decline in the number of banks continues in the 150 to 200 range for the next three years, the banking system will drop to between 5,700 and 5,800 banks by the end of 2015.  These numbers are above the 4,000 number that I had been predicting over the last couple of years but are still stunning given that there were 14,000 commercial banks in the banking system early in my banking career.

Regardless of the exact number, there are few reasons for new commercial banks to be formed and there are plenty of reasons why existing commercial banks will continue to consolidate.  This will mean that there will be fewer and fewer of the smaller banks in the banking system and more and more larger banks. 

Right now, according to the FDIC statistics, the largest 525 commercial banks in the United States (about 8 percent of the banks in the system) hold almost 91 percent of the assets in the banking system.  According to Federal Reserve statistics, the largest 25 domestically chartered commercial banks in the United States hold approximately two-thirds of all the assets in domestically chartered commercial banks.

In a real sense, the small- to medium-sized banks are almost irrelevant to the banking system except that their failure or clumsy exit could cause trouble to the rest of the system.   

Whether you like it or not, the number of banking units in the United States is shrinking relatively rapidly and more and more of the assets of the banking system are being found in the larger banking institutions.  And, this does not include the impact of the growing number of foreign commercial banks that are becoming players in the United States. 

Given the weakness in the commercial banking sector it is not surprising that bank loans are not showing much bounce.  Loan balances at FDIC-insured commercial banks declined in the first quarter of 2012 by slightly more than $56 billion. This decline occurred after loans had increased modestly over the previous three quarters.  Loan increases generally took place at the larger commercial banks. 

Revenues and bank profits continue to rise, but most of the increase, as expected, came in commercial banks that had more than $1.0 billion in assets.

It is still my belief that the general thrust of the monetary policy of the Federal Reserve is to keep commercial banks open and operating so that the FDIC can continue to close the weaker institutions in an orderly fashion and to allow the stronger, larger banking institutions to acquire the weaker ones, who are generally the smaller banks.  This strategy will continue to be followed until the condition of the banking industry improves sufficiently to grow stronger on its own.

Continued weakness in bank lending, particularly at the smaller institutions, will signal to us that the banking system, as a whole, has not fully recovered from the financial crisis that took place several years ago. 

This continued weakness in bank lending will also contribute to tepid growth in the economy as consumers and small- and medium-sized businesses cannot obtain the funds they need to spend and expand.  All these pieces seem to go together.       

Friday, May 4, 2012

Small Banks Unlikely to be Able to Repay Bailout Funds


“Most small banks bailed out by US taxpayers during the financial crisis are unlikely to be able to repay the Treasury department, the Obama administration says.” (http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/bc09f03c-9562-11e1-8faf-00144feab49a.html#axzz1tp5ngu6K)

This came out in a blog post on the Treasury’s website yesterday. See “Winding Down TARP’s Bank Program,” by Timothy Massad, assistant Treasury secretary for financial stability. (http://www.treasury.gov/connect/blog/Pages/Winding-Down-TARPs-Bank-Programs.aspx)

 The Treasury does not expect “the majority of the nearly 350 lenders still partially owned by US taxpayers to repurchase in the next 12-18 months the preferred stock that Treasury received in exchange for bailing them out.”

The “smaller” banks are defined as those with less that $10 billion in assets. 

This is just another piece of information that keeps leaking out that the state of the health of the US banking system is still not what it should be.  We await new information from the FDIC on the number of commercial banks still on its problem list. 

On December 31, 2011 there were more than 800 institutions still on the FDIC’s problem list.  And, we know the problem list does not include all those banks that are “troubled.”  The FDIC not only oversees the closing of troubled banks, it also is active in assisting “acquisitions” of banks that are experiencing difficulties.  In 2011, for example, there were 92 banks that closed.  However, from December 31, 2010 to December 31, 2011, 240 banks dropped out of the banking system.

The point is, the banking system is still not out of the woods.  I am still standing by my prediction that the banking system will decline by more than 2,000 institutions over the next five years, dropping from 6,290 banks on December 31, 2011 to less than 4,000. 

This decline will take place as the bigger banks in the United States become even bigger and as more and more big foreign banks increase their presence in the US.  On this last note I refer you to the list of the world’s strongest banks published by Bloomberg Markets magazine.  Of the top 10 strongest banks in the world, four were from Canada, and there were two more near these, one coming in as the 18th strongest and one as the 22nd strongest. (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-05-02/canadians-dominate-world-s-10-strongest-banks.html)  

Note: only three American banks showed up in the top twenty, JPMorgan Chase at number 13, PNC Financial Services Group at number 17, and BB&T Coro. at number 20.

Adding to this movement, let me just add two more aspects of the future of banking that work against the smaller banks.  First, there are the advancements in technology taking place in the world.  Banks are becoming more and more wired (just notice the new bond trading platform introduced yesterday by Goldman Sachs, a development that is highly dependent upon scale) and more and more mobile.  As the world, even the world of Main Street becomes more connected, the smaller banks will be less able to compete.

Second, the “shadow banking” sector continues to grow.  The “new” idea is for banks to outsource some of their “core” small business lending to a new crop of loan funds…”shadow banks.” (http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/85ce3bde-9546-11e1-8faf-00144feab49a.html#axzz1tp5ngu6K) Financial innovation continues to accelerate.

And, how important is shadow banking?  Well, take a look at the accompanying charts.  



Shadow banking is huge and is growing.  The smaller banks will not be able to compete with them. (http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/3/981cb220-8a47-11e1-93c9-00144feab49a.html#axzz1tp5ngu6K)

The United States banking system still has major adjustments to go through.  The structure of banking is changing.  Whereas America has always had a “small bank” culture…my banker grandfather was a staunch advocate of “unit” banking where a bank could only have one branch and must keep its business interests within that state.  Within the current environment, however, is the Canadian banking system, where there are only eight oligopoly banks, more realistic?

The United States banking system is not stable in its current position.  Huge changes are to be expected.  With the Treasury blog post we understand that there still is a solvency problem.  The Fed will continue to keep excess reserves in the banking system to preserve as much stability as possible for the health of the economy.  The economy and the financial system are heading in the right direction but it takes a long time to unwind 50 years or so of economic mis-management.  We must understand the still fragile condition of the financial system in order to understand why the government and the regulators are acting the way they are. 

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

More News on the Troubled Banking System: The TARP Report

Reports concerning the banking system keep popping up from time-to-time that continue to cause us to pause and wonder about the financial health of the banking system. 

We do not get information directly from the Federal Reserve System or the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation about the state of commercial banks. 

However, we see that the Federal Reserve has pumped over $1.5 trillion in excess reserves into the banking system.  The Fed tells us that the quantitative easy that has created these excess reserves is to help spur on economic growth.  Yet, there still lingers a doubt about the real financial condition of the banking system and about the possibility that the Fed is keeping the banking system excessively liquid so as to keep banks, especially the smaller ones, afloat so that the FDIC can either close the weaker ones or assist others to merge into healthier banks in a smooth and orderly fashion. 

The FDIC, at last count, still had well over 800 commercial banks on its problem bank list.  So far this year the FDIC has closed about one bank per week.  The information we don’t have is the number of banks that have been merged out of existence this year.  Last year about five banks left the banking system every week either through being closed or by being merged out of existence. 

Now, Christy Romero, special inspector general for the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP), has released information indicating that “351 small banks with some $15 billion in outstanding TARP loans face a ‘significant challenge’ in raising new funds to repay the government.” (http://professional.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303978104577364262736412398.html?mod=ITP_moneyandinvesting_0&mg=reno64-sec-wsj)

This information was released in connection with her quarterly report to Congress. 

The total of $15 billion is not a small number.  If one looks at the FDIC statistics, as of December 31, 2011, there were 5,776 commercial banks that had assets of $1.0 billion or less.  The total of 351 banks only represents about six percent of the commercial banks of this size, but the $15 billion debt to TARP is approximately 12 percent of the Total Equity Capital of these banks. 

Why did these commercial banks need so much TARP money?  Well, the TARP money was supposed to provide liquidity relief to these organizations so that they would not have to get rid of underwater assets that would threaten their solvency.  They needed the TARP money because so many commercial banks had become “liability management” banks using purchased funds to support their asset portfolios. 

The only commercial banks that used to be “liability management” banks were the larger banks that could go into the money markets and purchase funds at market rates.  The larger banks purchased monies through the market for negotiable certificates of deposit and the Eurodollar market and similar other “liquid” markets.

Over the past twenty years or so almost all commercial banks, even some very small ones became “liability managers” as they used different forms of purchased funds to allow them to bid more aggressively for riskier assets or to grow faster than their local “communities” would allow.  Government agencies, like the Federal Home Banks even encouraged this behavior by making loans available to smaller banks…and thrift banks…so that they could grow and build their asset portfolios. 

I was just amazed this past year.  Given a bank transaction I was involved in I had the opportunity to take a webinar on Asset/Liability management offered by the American Bankers Association.  Within the material presented in this webinar was substantial information on how banks…small and smaller banks…could or should use purchased funds.  Not demand deposits or savings deposits supposedly the bread-and-butter of community banks, but purchased funds from outside the “community.”

Main Street was attempting to play the game like Wall Street!

This plays right into the TARP scenario.  These “smaller” banks were using purchased funds to support assets of different flavors and assortments.  As these assets dropped “underwater” and as the purchased funds had to be rolled-over, the banks, to avoid having to take losses by selling the assets, obtained TARP funds to allow them to keep the assets on their books.

This was exactly the purpose of the government troubled asset program.

Now, here we are a couple of years later.  The assets are apparently still underwater which means that the TARP funds cannot be repaid.  And, the banks are in such bad condition that they cannot even pay the quarterly dividends that are owed to the Treasury. 

According to the Report, in the first quarter of 2012, 200 TARP banks failed to make their latest payment.  The shortfall in dividend payments is $416 million!

So, we have some more evidence that the banking system is not “out-of-the-woods” yet in terms of its solvency issues.  Given this conclusion it is understandable that the Federal Reserve and the FDIC are aiming to err on the side of too much ease and very strict oversight.  One can guess that this posture will not end soon.

Furthermore, the bigger banks are just going to become a larger and larger part of the whole banking system.    

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

FDIC Statistics: Larger Banks Doing Better Than Others

The FDIC statistics were released this morning.  The larger banks continue to prosper relative to the rest of the industry.  The larger banks in this case are those that are larger than $1.0 billion in asset size. 

For one, over the past year, the number of larger banks in the United States rose by 5 whereas the rest of the commercial banking system shrunk by 245 banks.  Of the total reduction in commercial banks in the United States of 240 in 2011, only 92 banks were closed by the FDIC. The rest were merged into other organizations. 

A total of 185 banks smaller than $100 million in asset size were closed.

At December 31, 2011, the commercial banking system had 62 fewer banks than on September 30, 2011.  Of this number, 66 were smaller than $100 million in assets.  The FDIC closed only 18 banks in the fourth quarter.

In terms of lending, net loans and leases at the largest 514 banks in the country rose by about $194 billion in 2011, with $137 billion of the increase coming in the fourth quarter of the year. 

This increase is coming in the face of an improving loan portfolio.  Noncurrent loans and leases at these larger banks fell by $44 billion over the past year while the loan loss allowance at these banks dropped by $38 billion.

It appears that the largest commercial banks in the country are feeling better about their loan portfolios and are becoming much more aggressive in actually making new loans. 

This is not the case for the other banks.  For banks that hold assets somewhere between $100 million and $1.0 billion, net loans and leases actually declined by about $31 billion in 2011.  For the fourth quarter of the year net loans and leases held about constant. 

For commercial banks with less than $100 million in assets loans declined by about $8 billion for the whole year and by about $3 billion for the fourth quarter of 2011.

In both of these smaller categories both noncurrent loans and leases fell but by relatively small amounts as did the loan loss allowances held by these organizations. 

The list of problem banks dropped in the fourth quarter by 31 banks to 814 commercial banks on December 31, 2011.  This total was down from 884 banks on the problem list on December 31, 2010. 

814 banks on the problem list is still a very large number representing 13 percent of the number of commercial banks insured by the FDIC.  And, this 814 banks does not included other organizations that are still in very deep trouble but do not yet qualify to be placed on the problem bank list.  The number of banks on the problem list and near being on the problem list could total about one-third of the banking system.

And, in the fourth quarter of 2011 we saw that the number of banks in the industry was still dropping at an annual rate of about 250 banks leaving the system every year.  

Bottom line: the banking system is still not very healthy.  Going further I would argue that the smaller banks are especially not “out-of-the-woods” in terms of problems.  The continuing problems being experienced in the housing market and in commercial real estate will weigh heavily on these smaller banks as we go along.  And, don’t expect much lending from them.

The largest 514 commercial banks continue to grow.  In terms of number, commercial banks with more than $1.0 billion in assets represent only about 8 percent of the organizations in the industry.  However, in terms of assets held, these larger banks hold 91 percent of the assets in the commercial banking industry and 89 percent of the loans.  Their bad assets seem to be decreasing as a problem and their loan growth appears to be getting stronger every quarter. 

Everything we see points to the continued demise of the smaller banks in the industry.  And, there appears to be nothing on the horizon to turn this trend around.